XbinaryBrwnfanartist has limited the viewing of this artwork to members of the DeviantArt community only.
You can log in or become a member for FREE.

Deviation Actions

XbinaryBrwnfanartist's avatar

Everyone loves an execution

Published:
146 Views

Description

Fullmetal Alchemist is Hiromu Arakawa's.

First anime handles Roy's killing the Homunculus very carefully. We see Roy set Pride on fire and then the camera cuts away. The camera only returns once Pride is dissolving into the floor. Roy is also exhausted, increasing our sympathy for him and dead Selim, and taking the edge off the fact that Roy has just repeatedly burned someone alive. Roy is basically put in the role of a torturer and executioner, but the one executed was not innocent, it's viewed by the audience as an act of solemn justice.  

In Brotherhood the camera gazes invasively as Roy torches Lust. We see her from every angle as she's regenerating and as she's being incinerated repeatedly. Every detail of her exposed viscera is shown to us by the unrelenting camera. As Roy is consumed by vengeful bloodlust, we are also consumed, because after all, Lust is just a monster--and worse, a feminine monster, so it's okay to destroy a monster, especially a monster who has done evil things. 

Brotherhood treated the Homunculi deaths as a nauseating spectacle. The story also expects us to sympathize with the humans destroying the monsters, feeding the characters', and the audience's---bloodlust and sadistic fascination with seeing torture and death in detail--that has its place in horror stories, but the story expects us to sympathize with Roy, the sadistic torturer and executioner, because he's the hero.

So here, I applied Brotherhood's logic to first anime. What do you think, dear readers?
Image size
640x480px 282.08 KB
Mature
© 2015 - 2024 XbinaryBrwnfanartist
Comments9
Join the community to add your comment. Already a deviant? Log In
karenjade's avatar
Mmm hmm, though to my mind the homunculus in the 2003 version were done differently then the manga canon and Brotherhood. In the 2003 they are the results of failed attempts to bring humans back to life, and thus show some degree of humanity which makes them sympathetic. Compare Lust in 2003- who was once an Ishbalian woman, deeply in love and wants to become human- to the canon & Brotherhood- where she really is a monster who considers humans beneath her- She is certainly more deserving of sympathy in the former and I can't say I blame Roy in the latter. However, things have changed by the time Roy's ready to kill Envy in Brotherhood...

Realistically, though, I can't say executions are something I take pleasure in, however much deserved.